What is the Difference Between Vanilla and French Vanilla?

Michael Pollick
Michael Pollick

While today's ice cream enthusiasts may view vanilla as a bland or generic offering, it used to be considered a very exotic flavor indeed. Because it became such a popular choice for consumers, vanilla became the standard bearer of the ice cream family, closely followed by chocolate and strawberry. The complex flavors created by the vanilla bean, a member of the orchid family, were never intended to become a generic base, however.

Dried vanilla beans.
Dried vanilla beans.

There are several variations on the standard vanilla flavor, including a particularly rich and creamy variety called French vanilla. While both traditional vanilla and French vanilla ice creams can still be used as a base for milkshakes and other dessert treats, there are a few differences between them. Traditional vanilla flavor is derived from the seeds of a vanilla bean pod, or at least a synthetic chemical equivalent called vanillin. French vanilla is more of an egg custard before freezing, and contains egg yolks for a richer consistency.

Vanilla ice cream might contain flecks of vanilla beans.
Vanilla ice cream might contain flecks of vanilla beans.

Traditional vanilla ice cream is also likely to contain small flecks of vanilla beans, but French vanilla is often strained to remove these flecks. Because of the egg yolks, French vanilla ice cream also appears to be a deeper shade of yellow than traditional vanilla ice cream. French vanilla ice cream is often viewed as creamier in texture than many standard vanilla ice cream brands, which may be a result of starting with a custard base instead of cream.

Vanilla is a popular flavor for pudding.
Vanilla is a popular flavor for pudding.

There is no difference between the vanilla flavoring used in standard or French vanilla ice cream. Vanilla beans are often distilled in alcohol to extract their complex flavors, and this extract is often used instead of natural vanilla beans when producing ice cream in bulk. Some brands of vanilla ice cream have flecks of real vanilla bean added during the mixing process, but their contribution to the actual flavor may be negligible. French vanilla ice cream is made with the same form of vanilla, but with a different base containing egg yolk.

The difference between vanilla and French vanilla is more obvious in the fragrance industry than the ice cream industry. "French Vanilla" is often marketed as a fragrance unto itself, whereas a standard vanilla fragrance is commonly blended with other floral or fruity fragrances to create a pleasing hybrid scent for air fresheners and other odor-masking products. The French vanilla scent is generally sweet and slightly buttery, while a standard vanilla scent is more floral and subdued.

The next time you find yourself enjoying a bowl of vanilla or French vanilla ice cream, try to get a sense of all of its complex flavors and textures. You may never look at plain old vanilla ice cream the same way again.

French vanilla is made from egg yolks to give it a richer consistency.
French vanilla is made from egg yolks to give it a richer consistency.
Michael Pollick
Michael Pollick

A regular wiseGEEK contributor, Michael enjoys doing research in order to satisfy his wide-ranging curiosity about a variety of arcane topics. Before becoming a professional writer, Michael worked as an English tutor, poet, voice-over artist, and DJ.

You might also Like

Discussion Comments


Honestly it really depends on your taste buds. I can taste as little as .05 percent alcohol. French vanilla flavoring vs vanilla flavoring are both remarkably different in taste but it's known that I have peculiarly sensitive taste. However to the one who wrote this article, they lack taste in general and didn't even consider that there are French vanilla flavorings for things other than ice cream. It's very distinctive in taste.

Obviously the only thing they are capable of distinguishing is scent. My mum herself has subpar taste buds and blurry vision but a miraculous dog nose.


Anyone have a recipe for cooked french-vanilla pudding like Jello used to make?


Nice article but I have a question. Is vanilla extract used in a French Vanilla flavored coffee?


So where can I find more info about vanilla beans?


Nice to know but that's for ice cream. Just wondering about other things like coffee or creamers etc. What's the difference between a vanilla flavored creamer and a French Vanilla?


Mmm. That's lovely!


bojiberry vanilla is the bomb of a flavor!!!!


I believe French vanilla ice cream contains more butterfat then does regular vanilla ice cream.


Many years ago I worked in a factory in Mitcham Surrey England.Where we were making Vanilla after working rather for just a couple of weeks people around me could tell when I was coming because the scent was embedded in my clothing and even my skin.

So strong was the scent.

Post your comments
Forgot password?